Lately I have been having an internal conflict about certain products that I regularly suggest as “cruelty-free” options for women on a budget. This consists of clothes, shoes and accessories from chain stores such as Forever 21, H&M, Target and other corporations that offer hoards of clothes for incredibly affordable prices. Although these products are technically vegan, it is more of an accidental side effect of cheap mass production. Sure $20 shoes are wonderful for our wallets but what effect do they have on the rest of the world?
Whenever we spend money on a purchase, we are supporting the industry and ethics behind the company. Our purchase is a vote towards that company and their practices. Do we really wish to support inhumane working conditions, environmental destruction, and corporate greed? Even if animal cruelty is not involved in the process, does that make it ok?
This recent revelation came when I made a quick stop by Forever 21 a few days ago to pick up some basic pieces that I so desperately needed. I spent a bit of time sifting through the endless racks of clothing and trying to control my heart palpitations induced by the cheapest fashionable clothes I had ever encountered. Upon returning home I dumped a huge pile of clothes onto the bed and marveled at the wonder of what $60 can buy. Then I thought about it. Why were these clothes so cheap? What corners are cut that make mass produced clothing so cheap and independently produced clothing so unbearably expensive? Why does this belt smell like poison?
Most cheap clothing is made in factories by underpaid workers doing their jobs in squalor. Unfortunately like many industries out there, these companies are expected to adhere to vague regulations and monitor production themselves. Think this is only an issue in Asian countries? Think again. It happens in the good ol US of A.
Conventional clothing production puts heaps of toxins into our air, water and bodies. It supports forest destruction and unfair situations for farmers. Cotton production uses more pesticides than any other single crop in the world!
Companies conveniently offering low prices push out small businesses and ruin local economies. They take business away from small shops owned by a single person devoted to quality goods and personal service.
It is often argued that these large businesses provide jobs, but in retail they typically employ people who do not give back to the local economy, and spend most of their money at their place of employment – like teenagers, or younger persons with no mortgage or property tax.
Large retail companies are known to throw out or even burn clothing after each season, instead of giving those garments to charities and people who could greatly use them.
Inexpensive clothing is not made as well as its designer or independent counterpart. After clothing falls apart, stretches or develops holes we are forced to go buy more clothing, creating more waste.
Many trendy chains (I’m looking at you Forever 21) rip off designers who have worked hard to develop their line and a quality product. They sell these sub-par rip-offs for ridiculously cheap prices, devaluing the work of real artists.
Supporting an industry that actively chooses to produce vegan, environmentally friendly, sustainable products will help make those products readily available and more affordable in the future.
Now the question is – How do we still wear fashionable, and affordable clothing while remaining an ethically well-rounded individual? THAT my friends is in Part 2 of this article.
Melanie says
great article. i totally can relate to your dilemma. i want to blog about vegan fashion for all budgets and sometimes the affordable stuff that just happens to vegan in not so friendly to our environment & people. I try to do my best to post more about the ethical vegan fashion but sometimes i do throw in a piece from H&M, Payless, etc… I look forward to the 2nd part of your post. cheers!
jesse.anne.o says
All good points! It's interesting because a lot of people who do style blogs cop to frequenting said blogs making them want more things even if we started the blogs for the opposite reason.
Franca did a good series of posts on this, too, if you haven't yet seen them:
http://orangesapples.blogspot.com/2010/06/im-lo…
And Already Pretty recently did one too.
But also looking forward to your 2nd post. It's great that this is recurring dialogue!
Natalie @ AngstLovesSpinach says
brilliant and well supported, Mandi. It's easy to lose the people in all our worry about the non-human animals. Thank you for stepping out and reminding us that when something seems too good to be true, it probably came at a great price to someone else.
Mandi (Chic Vegan) says
Thanks Nat.. glad you liked it!
Mandi (Chic Vegan) says
oh! good, good, good! Thanks for the links! Glad to see there is a collective enlightenment going on.
lauren says
Great post, this is something I struggle with so much. I am looking forward to part 2!
Silvia says
Can't wait for this….! I just want to know WHERE to shop. I'm willing to pay more-but not a whole lot-for eco-friendly, vegan and fair labor clothing. Is it really possible to do so w/out spending $80 on a T shirt? PLEASE, PLEASE DO PROVIDE US WITH RETAILER LINK INFO/OPTIONS. Many, MANY thanks. Silvia.
renurenu says
indeed, cruelty-free doesn't mean only free of the exploitation of animals but also of the one of humans.
mollyhorn says
This (and being vegan) is exactly why I only buy used, except for underthings. Used clothing is just as good as new, and is 100% better for the environment, for animals, and for the workers. Go Goodwill!
Jen says
Such a great post! Look forward to seeing the next in the series… Am so pleased that people are starting to tap into the ethics of fashion! Here's another ethical site to sink your teeth into… http://www.bluecaravan.net. Jen x
Mandi (Chic Vegan) says
Nice Shop! Thank you for sharing, I will add it to my resources page.
Part 2 is up with some basic ideas: https://www.chicvegan.com/the-art-of-finding-truly-e…
I'm thinking there is going to be a Part 3 to cover some more specific businesses and designers. I'll include your shop!
Jenzie says
This is very eye-opening! The circle of compassion should include all living people and consumers need to be aware of what types of corporate slavery they are supporting.